December 7, 2019 News Magazine

Mass media vs. social media

In the waning years of the last millennium, at my university, one of the cause célèbres of the progressive left was a concept known as “Manufacturing Consent,” the title of a book and film, by and starring Noam Chomsky. Its central thesis was that US mass media “are effective and powerful ideological institutions that carry out a system-supportive propaganda function, by reliance on market forces, internalized assumptions, and self-censorship.”

It’s fair to say that history has been pretty kind to this theory. Consider the support drummed up by mass media for the invasion of Iraq in 2003. To quote the public editor of the New York Times, “To anyone who read the paper between September 2002 and June 2003, the impression that Saddam Hussein possessed, or was acquiring, a frightening arsenal of W.M.D. seemed unmistakable. Except, of course, it appears to have been mistaken.” Consider the September 2002 dossier published by the UK government “to bolster support for war” which turned out to be full of spectacularly incorrect information, and the media’s failure to interrogate those claims.

It’s hard to overstate just how cataclysmic these errors were. If the mass media had pushed back against the false claims of weapons of mass destruction, we might have avoided the Iraq war, which killed hundreds of thousands and cost trillions of dollars. Saddam Hussein was not exactly a tough act to follow, but the US still managed to follow its falsely motivated war with a botched occupation which turned Iraq, and arguably the larger Middle East to this day, into a bloodbath.

An interesting question is: what would have happened if today’s social media had been around in 2003? Today, if a wrong assertion is promoted by the mass media, it doesn’t take long for subject-matter experts to appear on Facebook and Twitter, correcting them, and either going viral themselves or becoming the subjects of countervailing media stories.

This doesn’t necessarily mean catastrophe would have been averted. But at least a possible corrective to the collective hysteria of the mass media would have existed, unlike in 2002-3. (Yes, those were the days of Blogspot and LiveJournal, but they didn’t have anything like the reach or significance of today’s social media.)

Consider a more recent event: the 2016 American presidential election. It has become an article of faith, in certain quarters, that it was won and lost by the diabolical use of Facebook ads, especially in conjunction with the psychographic superscience of Cambridge Analytica. This is ridiculous. First, no one credible thinks CA’s purported ability to mind control Facebook users by showing them “psychographically” targeted ads was anything other than snake-oil nonsense.

Second, as Nate Silver points out, the impact of social-media ads was enormously less than the impact of mass media. Remember the months of hysteria about Hillary Clinton’s emails? Remember how it turned out to be a complete non-story? Doesn’t this remind you of Iraq’s WMDs?

“The media’s coverage of Hillary Clinton’s email scandal was probably literally 50 times more important to the outcome of the 2016 election than Trump ads on Facebook.” Perhaps, my fellow mass media, the fault lies not in our psychographic bullshit artists, but in ourselves

Social media has many downsides. You don’t have to go particularly deeply into my own back catalog to discover that I am a harsh critic of Facebook myself. But let’s not pretend that mass media, just because it’s older, is therefore perfect. It has its own catastrophic failure modes itself. In fact — whisper it — maybe we’re a lot better off, net, with social media and mass media, in that each can act as a counterbalancing corrective on the other’s flaws and failure modes.

The progressive left may have gone from “mass media is the enemy” to “Big Tech social media is the enemy,” but maybe, and I know this sounds crazy because it’s on the Internet, but hear me out here, maybe there’s room for a little nuance; maybe they both have good and bad aspects, and could possibly balance one another out. If you don’t think mass media needs a corrective, let me remind you once again of the Iraq War and But Her Emails, to name but two of many, many examples. Maybe there exists a future in which social and mass media are each a cure for what ails the other.


Source: TechCrunch

Tags: in Uncategorized
Banner
Related Posts

Watch the first trailer for ‘See’, Apple’s post-apocalyptic show starring Jason Momoa

September 10, 2019

September 10, 2019

While Apple’s big event today was largely focused on the iPhone 11 and other new devices, the company also offered updates...

Apple macOS security protections can easily bypassed with ‘synthetic’ clicks, researcher finds

June 3, 2019

June 3, 2019

A security researcher has disclosed a new flaw that undermines a core macOS security feature designed to prevent apps —...

Meet the robots Toyota is bringing to the 2020 Tokyo Olympic Games

July 22, 2019

July 22, 2019

Tokyo’s 2020 Summer Olympic and Paralympic Games are fast-approaching, and Toyota is playing a key role in on-site mobility and...

Should we rethink the politics of ‘blocking’?

October 20, 2019

October 20, 2019

Jillian C. York Contributor Share on Twitter Jillian C. York is the director for international freedom of expression at the...

Nintendo announces Super Mario Maker 2 for Switch, so goodbye forever

February 13, 2019

February 13, 2019

Nintendo has ruined my life, and all our lives, by announcing Super Mario Maker 2, the sequel to the level-constructing...

Corporate, public investments spur interest in Pacific Northwest startups

November 7, 2019

November 7, 2019

Dan Burgar Contributor Share on Twitter Dan Burgar is President of the Vancouver VR/AR Association, where he has helped develop...

Meet Bespoke Financial, a lender for cannabis companies backed by Snoop Dogg’s Casa Verde Capital

October 25, 2019

October 25, 2019

Bespoke Financial wants to provide cannabis businesses with the same kind of financial services that other businesses get, but that...

Google limits political ad targeting and all ‘demonstrably false claims’

November 21, 2019

November 21, 2019

Google has joined Twitter in revising its political ad rules ahead of what promises to be a brutal election season....

The remains of India’s first lunar lander have been found on the Moon

December 3, 2019

December 3, 2019

India’s Vikram lander was very near making its proud creators the fourth country in history to touch down on the...

Molecule.one uses machine learning to make synthesizing new drugs a snap

October 3, 2019

October 3, 2019

Say you’re a pharmaceutical company. You’ve figured out that a novel molecule could be effective in treating an illness —...

Flaws in a popular GPS tracker leak real-time locations and can remotely activate its microphone

May 10, 2019

May 10, 2019

A popular GPS tracker — used as a panic alarm for elderly patients, to monitor kids, and track vehicles —...

Crowdfunded spacecraft LightSail 2 delivers amazing images of its deployed solar sail

July 25, 2019

July 25, 2019

We got word yesterday that the crowdfunded LightSail 2 spacecraft had successfully deployed its mylar solar sail, a large sheet...

Oppo executive questions how foldable phones improve the user experience

February 25, 2019

February 25, 2019

Oppo VP Brian Shen took to Weibo today to unveil the company’s foldable phone concept. It looks like the same...

Watch Huawei’s MWC conference live right here

February 24, 2019

February 24, 2019

While Huawei isn’t going to show the P30 at Mobile World Congress, the company says it is going to “reveal...

Founders Factory is going live in Paris

June 20, 2019

June 20, 2019

After London and Johannesburg, startup accelerator and incubator Founders Factory is launching a third city — Paris. Once again, the...

Comments
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *